The Clinton Presidency:
Historic Economic Growth
In 1993, President Clinton and Vice President Gore launched their
economic strategy: (1) establishing fiscal discipline, eliminating the
budget deficit, keeping interest rates low, and spurring private-sector
investment; (2) investing in people through education, training,
science, and research; and (3) opening foreign markets so American
workers can compete abroad. After eight years, the results of President
Clinton's economic leadership are clear. Record budget deficits have
become record surpluses, 22 million new jobs have been created,
unemployment and core inflation are at their lowest levels in more than
30 years, and America is in the midst of the longest economic expansion
in our history.
President Clinton's Record on the Economy: In 1992, 10 million Americans
were unemployed, the country faced record deficits, and poverty and
welfare rolls were growing. Family incomes were losing ground to
inflation and jobs were being created at the slowest rate since the
Great Depression. Today, America enjoys what may be the strongest
economy ever.
- Strong Economic Growth: Since President Clinton and Vice President
Gore took office, economic growth has averaged 4.0 percent per
year, compared to average growth of 2.8 percent during the
Reagan-Bush years. The economy has grown for 116 consecutive
months, the most in history.
- Most New Jobs Ever Created Under a Single Administration: The
economy has created more than 22.5 million jobs in less than eight
years -- the most jobs ever created under a single administration,
and more than were created in the previous 12 years. Of the total
new jobs, 20.7 million, or 92 percent, are in the private sector.
- Median Family Income Up $6,000 since 1993: Economic gains have been
made across the spectrum as family incomes increased for all
Americans. Since 1993, real median family income has increased by
$6,338, from $42,612 in 1993 to $48,950 in 1999 (in 1999 dollars).
- Unemployment at Its Lowest Level in More than 30 Years: Overall
unemployment has dropped to the lowest level in more than 30 years,
down from 6.9 percent in 1993 to just 4.0 percent in November 2000.
The unemployment rate has been below 5 percent for 40 consecutive
months. Unemployment for African Americans has fallen from 14.2
percent in 1992 to 7.3 percent in October 2000, the lowest rate on
record. Unemployment for Hispanics has fallen from 11.8 percent in
October 1992 to 5.0 percent in October 2000, also the lowest rate
on record.
- Lowest Inflation since the 1960s: Inflation is at the lowest rate
since the Kennedy Administration, averaging 2.5 percent, and it is
down from 4.7 percent during the previous administration.
- Highest Homeownership Rate on Record: The homeownership rate
reached 67.7 percent for the third quarter of 2000, the highest
rate on record. In contrast, the homeownership rate fell from 65.6
percent in the first quarter of 1981 to 63.7 percent in the first
quarter of 1993.
- 7 Million Fewer Americans Living in Poverty: The poverty rate has
declined from 15.1 percent in 1993 to 11.8 percent last year, the
largest six-year drop in poverty in nearly 30 years. There are now
7 million fewer people in poverty than there were in 1993.
Establishing Fiscal Discipline and Paying off the National Debt
President Clinton's Record on Fiscal Discipline: Between 1981 and 1992,
the national debt held by the public quadrupled. The annual budget
deficit grew to $290 billion in 1992, the largest ever, and was
projected to grow to more than $455 billion by Fiscal Year (FY) 2000.
As a result of the tough and sometimes unpopular choices made by
President Clinton, and major deficit reduction legislation passed in
1993 and 1997, we have seen eight consecutive years of fiscal
improvement for the first time in America's history.
- Largest Surplus Ever: The surplus in FY 2000 is $237 billion -- the
third consecutive surplus and the largest surplus ever.
- Largest Three-Year Debt Pay-Down Ever: Between 1998-2000, the
publicly held debt was reduced by $363 billion -- the largest
three-year pay-down in American history. Under Presidents Reagan
and Bush, the debt held by the public quadrupled. Under the
Clinton-Gore budget, we are on track to pay off the entire publicly
held debt on a net basis by 2009.
- Lower Federal Government Spending: After increasing under the
previous two administrations, federal government spending as a
share of the economy has been cut from 22.2 percent in 1992 to 18
percent in 2000 -- the lowest level since 1966.
- Reduced Interest Payments on the Debt: In 1993, the net interest
payments on the debt held by the public were projected to grow to
$348 billion in FY 2000. In 2000, interest payments on the debt
were $125 billion lower than projected.
- Americans Benefit from Reduced Debt: Because of fiscal discipline
and deficit and debt reduction, it is estimated that a family with
a home mortgage of $100,000 might expect to save roughly $2,000 per
year in mortgage payments, like a large tax cut.
- Double Digit Growth in Private Investment in Equipment and
Software: Lower debt will help maintain strong economic growth and
fuel private investments. With government no longer draining
resources out of capital markets, private investment in equipment
and software averaged 13.3 percent annual growth since 1993,
compared to 4.7 percent during 1981 to 1992.
To Establish Fiscal Discipline, President Clinton:
- Enacted the 1993 Deficit Reduction Plan without a Single Republican
Vote. Prior to 1993, the debate over fiscal policy often revolved
around a false choice between public investment and deficit
reduction. The 1993 deficit reduction plan showed that deficit and
debt reductions could be accomplished in a progressive way by
slashing the deficit in half and making important investments in
our future, including education, health care, and science and
technology research. The plan included more than $500 billion in
deficit reduction. It also cut taxes for 15 million of the
hardest-pressed Americans by expanding the Earned Income Tax
Credit; created the Direct Student Loan Program; created the first
nine Empowerment Zones and first 95 Enterprise Communities; and
passed tax cuts for small businesses and research and development.
- Negotiated the Balanced Budget Agreement of 1997. In his 1997
State of the Union address, President Clinton announced his plan to
balance the budget for the first time in 27 years. Later that
year, he signed the Balanced Budget Act of 1997, a major bipartisan
agreement to eliminate the national budget deficit, create the
conditions for economic growth, and invest in the education and
health of our people. It provided middle-class tax relief with a
$500 per child tax credit and the Hope Scholarship and Lifetime
Learning tax credits for college. It also created the Children's
Health Insurance Program to serve up to 5 million children and made
landmark investments in education initiatives including educational
technology, charter schools, Head Start, and Pell Grants. Finally,
it added 20 more Empowerment Zones and 20 more rural Enterprise
Communities, included the President's plan to revitalize the
District of Columbia, and continued welfare reform though $3
billion in new resources to move welfare recipients to
private-sector jobs.
- Dedicated the Surplus to Save Social Security and Reduce the
National Debt. In his 1998 and 1999 State of the Union addresses,
President Clinton called on the nation to save the surplus until
the solvency of Social Security is assured. He also repeatedly
vetoed large Republican tax cut bills that would have jeopardized
our nation's fiscal discipline. The President's actions led to a
bipartisan consensus on saving the surplus and paying down the
debt.
- Extended Medicare Solvency from 1999 to 2025. When President
Clinton took office, Medicare was expected to become insolvent in
1999, then only six years away. The 1993 deficit reduction act
dedicated some of the taxes paid by Social Security beneficiaries
to the Medicare Trust Fund and extended the life of Medicare by
three years to 2002. Thanks to additional provisions to combat
waste, fraud and abuse and bipartisan cooperation in the 1997
balanced budget agreement, Medicare is now expected to remain
solvent until 2025.
Clinton-Gore Economic Policy Has Dramatically Improved the Economy
"My colleagues and I have been very appreciative of your [President
Clinton's] support of the Fed over the years, and your commitment to
fiscal discipline has been instrumental in achieving what in a few weeks
will be the longest economic expansion in the nation's history."
- Alan Greenspan, Federal Reserve Board Chairman, January 4, 2000, with
President Clinton at Chairman Greenspan's re-nomination announcement
"The deficit has come down, and I give the Clinton Administration and
President Clinton himself a lot of credit for that. [He] did something
about it, fast. And I think we are seeing some benefits."
- Paul Volcker, Federal Reserve Board Chairman (1979-1987), in
Audacity, Fall 1994
One of the reasons Goldman Sachs cites for the "best economy ever" is
that "on the policy side, trade, fiscal, and monetary policies have been
excellent, working in ways that have facilitated growth without
inflation. The Clinton Administration has worked to liberalize trade
and has used any revenue windfalls to reduce the federal budget
deficit."
- Goldman Sachs, March 1998
"Clinton's 1993 budget cuts, which reduced projected red ink by more
than $400 billion over five years, sparked a major drop in interest
rates that helped boost investment in all the equipment and systems that
brought forth the New Age economy of technological innovation and rising
productivity."
- Business Week, May 19, 1997
Opening World Markets to American Goods and Providing Leadership on
Globalization
President Clinton's Record on Trade and Globalization: In 1992, 10
million Americans were unemployed, new job creation was slow, and wages
were stagnant. Other nations' high trade barriers limited the ability
of American businesses and farmers to sell their goods abroad and
hampered economic recovery. Our trade policies failed to reflect our
values by failing to take into account the responsibility to protect our
environment, eliminate child labor and sweatshops, and protect the
rights of workers around the world. But today:
- 300 Trade Agreements: President Clinton has opened markets for U.S.
exports abroad and created American jobs through nearly 300 free
and fair trade agreements.
- The Most U.S. Exports Ever. Between 1992 and 2000, U.S. exports of
goods and services grew by 74 percent, or nearly $500 billion, to
top $1 trillion for the first time.
- 1.4 Million More Jobs due to Exports: Jobs supported by American
exports grew by 1.4 million between 1994 and 1998, with jobs
supported by exports paying about 13 percent to 16 percent above
the U.S. national average. Jobs related to goods exports pay, on
average, 13 to 16 percent higher than other jobs.
- Lowest Inflation since the 1960s: Inflation is at the lowest rate
since the Kennedy Administration, in part because global
competition has kept prices low. It has averaged 2.5 percent under
this Administration, down from 4.6 percent during the previous
administration.
To Create Trade Opportunities and Expand the Benefits of Globalization,
President Clinton:'
- Won Ratification of the North America Free Trade Association
(NAFTA) in 1993, creating the world's largest free trade zone of
the U.S., Canada, and Mexico. U.S. exports to Mexico grew 109
percent from 1993 to 1999, while exports to the rest of the world
grew by 49 percent.
- Won Approval of Permanent Normal Trade Relations with China. In
2000, Congress ratified permanent normal trade relations with
China. The agreement will integrate China into the world economy
through entry into the World Trade Organization (WTO), open Chinese
market to U.S. exports, slash Chinese tariffs, and protect American
workers and companies against dumping.
- Successfully Completed the Uruguay Round. The 1994 Uruguay Round
transformed the world trading system, opening markets in a wide
range of industries, enabling the U.S. to enforce agreements more
effectively, and applying the rules for the first time to all WTO
members (now 138 in total).
- Fought for the First-Ever African and the Caribbean Basin Trade
Bills. The African Growth and Opportunity Act of 2000 will support
increased trade and investment between the United States and
Africa, strengthen African economies and democratic governments,
and increase partnerships to counter terrorism, crime,
environmental degradation and disease. The legislation will also
create incentives for the countries of sub-Saharan Africa and the
Caribbean Basin to continue reforming their economies.
- Promoted Trade Opportunities for High Technology. The Clinton
Administration completed series of trade agreements on technology,
including the WTO's commitment to duty-free cyberspace, keeping the
Internet free of trade barriers, in 1998; the global WTO agreements
on Financial Services and Basic Telecommunications in 1997; the
global WTO agreement on Information Technology in 1996; and a
series of bilateral agreements on intellectual property, high-tech
products, services and other sectors. These efforts are the
building blocks of the New Economy.
- Secured Historic Debt Relief. In March 1999, President Clinton
presented a plan to a U.S.-Africa Summit in Washington that became
the basis for the G-7 agreement in Cologne, Germany (known as the
Cologne Debt Initiative). The plan would triple the amount of debt
relief available for poor countries, reducing their debt by about
70 percent ($90 billion), in return for firm commitments to channel
the benefits into improving the lives of all their people. In
September 1999, the President announced that the U.S. would
unilaterally exceed the terms of the G-7 initiative and entirely
cancel the $5.7 billion in U.S. government debt owed by qualifying
countries. In November 2000, President Clinton won $435 million
from Congress for U.S. participation in the Cologne Initiative.
- Dramatically Expanded U.S. Efforts to Fight Child Labor and Expand
Basic Education. In June 1999, the President traveled to the
International Labor Organization (ILO) conference in Geneva,
Switzerland, to urge adoption of an historic international
convention banning the worst forms of child labor. He won $30
million for ILO enforcement of child labor laws and is fighting for
a new initiative to promote basic education in areas of the world
where child labor is widespread. In 2000, at U.S. urging, the G-8
countries endorsed the goal of universal basic education.
President Clinton brought other issues to the forefront of the
international economic agenda, including incorporating labor and
environmental considerations in the work of major international
economic institutions, increasing U.S. support for global efforts
to fight HIV-AIDS and infectious diseases, and closing the digital
divide.
- Defused International Economic Crises. In 1995, after Congress
refused to act, President Clinton made $20 billion in emergency
loans to Mexico to stabilize the country's financial markets.
Mexico repaid the loans in full, with interest, three years ahead
of schedule. Following the Asian and Russian financial crises in
1997 and 1998, the Clinton-Gore Administration led a global effort
to re-capitalize the International Monetary Fund to allow it to
more effectively deal with these problems. President Clinton also
insisted that the G-7 develop a set of measures to restore
confidence in the world financial system.
- Promoted U.S. Competitiveness. The Clinton-Gore Administration has
made key investments in education and training for American workers
and research and development. It has also maintained federal
fiscal discipline, helping to reduce interest rates, encourage
private-sector investment, and keep productivity high.
Rewarding Work and Empowering Communities
President Clinton's Record on Rewarding Work: In 1992, unemployment
reached 7.5 percent, the highest level in eight years. Unemployment and
poverty rates for African Americans and Hispanics were alarming:
unemployment reached 14.2 percent for African Americans and 11.8 percent
for Hispanics, and poverty rates for both groups were nearly 30 percent.
But today:
- Higher Incomes at All Levels: After years of stagnant income growth
among average and lower-income families, all income brackets have
experienced double-digit income growth since 1993. The bottom 20
percent saw the largest income growth at 16.3 percent.
- Lowest Poverty Rate in 20 Years: Since Congress passed President
Clinton's Economic Plan in 1993, the poverty rate declined from
15.1 percent to 11.8 percent last year, the largest six-year drop
in poverty in nearly 30 years. There are now 7 million fewer
people in poverty than there were in 1993. The child poverty rate
has declined more than 25 percent, the poverty rate for single
mothers is the lowest ever, the African American and elderly
poverty rates dropped to their lowest level on record, and the
Hispanic poverty rate dropped to its lowest level since 1979.
- Lowest Poverty Rate for Single Mothers on Record: Under President
Clinton, the poverty rate for families with single mothers has
fallen from 46.1 percent in 1993 to 35.7 percent in 1999, the
lowest level on record. Between 1980 and 1992, an additional 2.1
million households headed by single women were pushed into poverty.
- Smallest Welfare Rolls Since 1969: Under the Clinton-Gore
Administration, the welfare rolls have dropped dramatically and are
now the lowest since 1969. Between January 1993 and September of
1999, the number of welfare recipients dropped by 7.5 billion (a 53
percent decline) to 6.6 million. In comparison, between 1981-1992,
the number of welfare recipients increased by 2.5 million (a 22
percent increase) to 13.6 million people.
To Help All Americans Benefit from Prosperity, President Clinton:
- Ended Welfare as We Knew It. In 1996, President Clinton signed
legislation requiring welfare recipients to work, limiting the time
they can stay on welfare, and providing child care and health care
to help them begin work. It also enacted tough new child support
enforcement measures proposed by the President. In 1997, President
Clinton won the welfare-to-work tax credit to encourage employers
to hire long-term welfare recipients and $3 billion in additional
resources to help communities move long-term welfare recipients
into lasting, unsubsidized jobs.
- Rewarded Work by Expanding the Earned Income Tax Credit. In 1993,
President Clinton succeeded in winning passage of an expansion of
the Earned Income Tax Credit, giving a tax cut to 15 million of the
hardest-pressed American workers. In 1999, the EITC lifted 4.1
million people out of poverty, nearly double the number lifted out
of poverty by the EITC in 1993.
- Created Empowerment Zones. The 1993 Clinton-Gore economic plan
created nine Empowerment Zones and 95 Enterprise Communities to
spur local community planning and economic growth in distressed
communities through tax incentives and federal investment. The
President won expansions of the program in 1994, 1997, and again in
2000. To date, the 31 Empowerment Zones and 95 Enterprise
Communities have leveraged over $10 billion in new private sector
investment, creating thousands of new jobs for local residents.
- Created Community Development Financial Institutions. In September
1994, the President signed legislation creating the Community
Development Financial Institutions (CDFI) Fund, a Clinton campaign
proposal to support specialized financial institutions serving
often-overlooked customers and communities. The Fund has certified
over 400 CDFIs. It has provided over $427 million to match
investments in CDFIs and to encourage traditional financial
institutions to increase their lending, investment and services in
under-served markets.
- Strengthened the Community Reinvestment Act. In 1995, the
Administration updated the Community Reinvestment Act regulations
to focus on banks' actual service delivery, rather than on
compliance efforts. From 1993 to 1998, lenders subject to the law
increased mortgage lending to low- and moderate-income families by
80 percent -- more than twice the rate they increased mortgage
lending to other income groups.
- Encouraged Investment in America's New Markets. In 1999, the
President went on two historic "New Markets" trips to highlight the
continuing need to bring investment to impoverished inner cities,
rural communities and Native American tribal lands. In 2000, the
President and Congress worked together to pass this bipartisan
initiative to stimulate new private capital investments in
economically distressed communities and build network of private
investment institutions to funnel credit, equity and technical
assistance to businesses in America's new markets.
- Raised the Minimum Wage. In 1996, President Clinton and Vice
President Gore fought for and won a 90-cent per hour increase in
the minimum wage, helping 10 million workers.
- Helped People with Disabilities Work. In 1999, President Clinton
insisted that Congress pass the Work Incentives Improvement Act as
a condition of the budget agreement. This bipartisan law allows
people with disabilities to maintain their Medicare or Medicaid
coverage when they work.
Modernizing for the New Economy through Technology and Consensus
Deregulation
To Capitalize on the Information Technology Revolution, President
Clinton and Vice President Gore Have:
- Modernized Financial Services Laws. In 1993, the laws that
governed America's financial service sector were antiquated and
anti-competitive. The Clinton-Gore Administration fought to
modernize those laws to increase competition in traditional
banking, insurance, and securities industries to give consumers and
small businesses more choices and lower costs. In 1994, the
Clinton-Gore Administration broke another decades-old logjam by
allowing banks to branch across state lines in the Riegle-Neal
Interstate Banking and Branching Efficiency Act of 1994. President
Clinton fought for and won financial modernization legislation,
signing the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act in November 1999.
- Reformed Telecommunications. In 1996, President Clinton signed
legislation to open up competition between local telephone
companies, long distance providers and cable companies. The law
also requires the use of new V-chip technology to give families
greater control over which television programming comes into their
homes.
- Created the E-Rate. With the leadership of Vice President Gore,
the Telecommunications Act contained the E-Rate initiative, which
provides low-cost Internet connections for schools, libraries,
rural health clinics and hospitals. More than 80 percent of
America's public schools have benefited from the E-rate, which has
helped connect 30 million children and up to 47,000 schools and
libraries to the Internet. The percentage of public schools
connected to the Internet has increased from 35 percent in 1994 to
95 percent in 1999. The percentage of classrooms connected to the
Internet has increased from 3 percent in 1994 to 63 percent in
1999.
- Increased Resources for Educational Technology by Over 3,000
Percent. President Clinton and Vice President Gore increased our
investment in educational technology by over 3,000 percent, from
$23 million in FY 1994 to $769 million in FY 2000, including
training over 600,000 new teachers to use technology effectively in
the classroom.
- Paved the Way for Electronic Commerce. President Clinton fought to
eliminate legal barriers to using electronic technology to form and
sign contracts, collect and store documents, and send and receive
notices and disclosures, while ensuring that consumers on-line have
the same protections that they have in the paper world. He signed
the Electronic Signatures in Global and National Commerce Act on
June 30, 2000.
- Creating Market Opportunities for Technology Firms. The
Clinton-Gore Administration adopted a market-led approach on
e-commerce, making spectrum available for digital wireless, and
reforming Cold War export controls.
- Worked to Close the Digital Divide. Since 1992, the President and
Vice President have tripled funding for Community Technology
Centers, which provide access to computers and the Internet to
low-income urban and rural neighborhoods. President Clinton also
challenged the private sector to develop new business models for
low-cost computers and Internet access to make universal access at
home affordable for all Americans. The Technology Literacy
Challenge Fund has provided $1 billion in federal resources to help
schools work with businesses and community organizations to put
modern computers, high-quality educational software, and affordable
connections to the Internet in every classroom. The Taxpayer
Relief Act of 1997 created a temporary tax deduction for donations
of computers to elementary and secondary schools.
- Forged Trade Agreements on High Technology. The Clinton
Administration completed series of trade agreements on technology,
including the WTO's commitment to duty-free cyberspace, keeping the
Internet free of trade barriers, in 1998; the global WTO agreements
on Financial Services and Basic Telecommunications in 1997; the
global WTO agreement on Information Technology in 1996; and a
series of bilateral agreements on intellectual property, high-tech
products, services and other sectors; all soon to be capped by the
opening of a major networked economy initiative.
Investing in Educating and Training the American People
President Clinton's Record on Investing in Americans:
- More Americans Are Enrolling in College: 66 percent of 1998 high
school graduates enrolled in college or trade school the next fall,
compared to 60 percent in 1990.
- More High School Students Are Preparing for College: The percentage
of high school graduates who have taken four years of English and
three years each of math, science, and social studies increased
from 38 percent to 55 percent between 1990 and 1998. Research
shows that high-quality academics in high school is key to college
success.
- More Americans Are Earning College Degrees: Over 32 percent of 25-
to 29-year-old high school graduates had earned at least a
bachelor's degree in 1999, up from 27 percent in 1990. In
particular, white and African American women have seen their
college opportunities grow.
- Americans Are Becoming Lifelong Learners: 50 percent of adults
participated in formal learning in the year prior to a 1999 survey,
up from 38 percent in 1991.
To Provide Americans with More, Higher-Quality Education and Training,
President Clinton:
- Created the College Tax Credits, the Largest Single Investment in
Higher Education since the G.I. Bill. A $1,500 tax credit for the
first two years of college, the Hope Scholarship will pay for
nearly all of a typical community college's tuition and fees. The
$1,000 Lifetime Learning Tax Credit reimburses families for 20
percent of their tuition and fees (up to $5,000 per family) for
college, graduate study, or job training. Starting in 2003, the
credit will reimburse families for 20 percent of their costs up to
$10,000, for a maximum value of $2,000. This year, 10 million
American families will save over $7 billion through the college tax
credits.
- Doubled Student Financial Aid. Students will receive over $50
billion in federal grants, loans, and work-study aid this year, up
from $25 billion in 1993. President Clinton has consistently
supported budget increases for Pell Grants; this year, over 3.8
million needy students receive a Pell Grant scholarship of up to
$3,300, a $1,000 larger maximum grant than in 1993. The President
won another increase for Pell Grants in the FY 2001 budget,
bringing the maximum grant to $3,750. The President also won
increases in work-study funding to help one million students pay
for college.
- Created Direct Student Loans and Reduced Interest Rates. In the
Student Loan Reform Act of 1993, President Clinton won the Direct
Student Loan program to improve customer service and compete with
guaranteed lenders. It has saved taxpayers over $4 billion so far
by eliminating lender subsidies. President Clinton also fought to
reduce interest rates and fees in the Student Loan Reform Act of
1993 and the Higher Education Amendments of 1998. As a result,
students can expect to pay $1,300 less in interest and fees for the
average $10,000 loan than they would have in 1992. The student
loan default rate is now 6.9 percent, down from 22.4 percent eight
years ago.
- Created New Paths to College through GEAR UP, AmeriCorps, and TRIO.
President Clinton won the new GEAR UP initiative in the Higher
Education Amendments of 1998 which is already helping 700,000
low-income middle school students prepare for college. Over
150,000 Americans have earned money for college while serving their
communities through President Clinton's AmeriCorps program, a
campaign promise enacted in 1993. To help disadvantaged youth
prepare for and succeed in college, the TRIO programs have grown by
$342 million over the past eight years.
- Strengthened Elementary and Secondary Education. In 1994,
President Clinton reformed federal education initiatives in the
Improving America's Schools Act and the Goals 2000 Act. The
President's new approach was grounded in the principles that all of
America's students should meet high academic standards and the
federal government should make new investments to help them meet
those standards. The President has also fought to hire 100,000
teachers, promote educational technology, support charter schools,
build K-16 partnerships, and focus on early reading through America
Reads.
- Passed the Workforce Investment Act of 1998. In 1992, President
Clinton and Vice President Gore proposed to streamline and bring
greater accountability to our nation's job training system. In
1998, they won legislation to meet the needs of both America's
workers and businesses by encouraging local control of training and
employment programs; helping customers locate assistance through
one-stop centers; and empower adults to receive the training they
need. Reducing Tax Burdens for Average and Hard-Pressed Working
Families.
The Clinton Record on Reducing Taxes for Working Families:
- Lowest Federal Income Tax Burden in 35 Years: Federal income taxes
as a percentage of income for the typical American family have
dropped to their lowest level in 35 years.
- Higher Incomes even after Taxes and Inflation: Real after-tax
incomes have grown for Americans at all income levels, much faster
than they did prior to the Clinton-Gore Administration. Real
after-tax incomes grew by an average of 2.6 percent per year for
the lower-income half of taxpayers between 1993 and 1997, while
growing by an average of 1.0 percent between 1981 and 1993.
To Cut Taxes for Working Americans, President Clinton:
- Expanded the Earned Income Tax Credit. In 1993, President Clinton
succeeded in expanding the Earned Income Tax Credit, giving a tax
cut to 15 million of the hardest-pressed American workers. In
1999, the EITC lifted 4.1 million people out of poverty, nearly
double the number lifted out of poverty by the EITC in 1993.
- Created the $500 per Child Tax Credit. In 1997, President Clinton
secured a $500 per child tax credit for 27 million families with
children under 17, including 13 million children from families with
incomes below $30,000.
- Won the Hope Scholarship Tax Credit. President Clinton proposed tax
credits for college tuition in 1996 and signed them into law in
1997 as part of the balanced budget agreement. The Hope Scholarship
provides a tax credit of up to $1,500 for tuition and fees for the
first two years of college, roughly equal to the cost of the
average community college. It will save American families $4.9
billion this year.
- Won the Lifetime Learning Tax Credit. Also enacted in 1997, the
Lifetime Learning tax credit provides a 20 percent tax credit on
$5,000 of tuition and fees (to be raised to $10,000 in 2003) for
college and graduate students and adults taking job training. It
will reduce the cost of college and job training for American
families by $2.4 billion this year.
- Established Education IRAs. The 1997 balanced budget agreement also
created Education IRAs. For each child under age 18, families may
now deposit $500 per year into an Education IRA in the child's
name. Earnings in the Education IRA accumulate tax-free and no
taxes will be due upon withdrawal if the money is used to pay for
college. The law also allowed taxpayers to withdraw funds from a
traditional IRA without penalty to pay for higher education for
themselves or their spouse, child, or even grandchild.
- Created Empowerment Zones. President Clinton created Empowerment
Zones and Enterprise Communities in 1993 and expanded them in 1994,
1997 and again in 2000 to spur economic growth in distressed
communities through tax incentives and federal investment. To
date, the 31 Empowerment Zones and 95 Enterprise Communities have
leveraged over $10 billion in new private sector investment,
creating thousands of new jobs for local residents.
- Simplified Pension Rules. In 1996, President Clinton signed the
SIMPLE (Savings Incentive Match Plan for Employees) plan into law,
simplifying and expanding retirement plan coverage for small
businesses.
- Simplified Tax Laws and Protected Taxpayer Rights. President
Clinton signed the Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997 to simplify the tax
laws and enhance taxpayers' rights. The law has saved families and
businesses millions of hours be simplifying and reducing paperwork,
such as allowing a tax exclusion for income from the sale of a
home.
- Closed Tax Loopholes. To ensure that all taxpayers pay their fair
share, the Clinton Administration addressed the use and
proliferation of corporate tax shelters by proposing several
remedies to curb the growth of such shelters by increasing
disclosure of sheltering activities, increasing and strengthening
the substantial understatement penalty, codifying the
judicially-created economic substance doctrine, and providing
consequences to all parties involved in an abusive sheltering
transaction.
PRESIDENT CLINTON'S ECONOMIC POLICIES HAVE MADE A DIFFERENCE
Trade Expands Opportunity for American Workers
"Harley-Davidson is growing rapidly, and sales to other countries is one
reason why. President Clinton's efforts to open foreign markets have
made a difference and helped create jobs at Harley-Davidson."
- Bobby Ramsey began working at the Harley-Davidson York plant in 1972
and is now responsible for inspecting all incoming motorcycle parts
prior to the assembly process. Since 1995, Mr. Ramsey has also been his
union's Chief Shop Steward, which entails handling all second step
grievances of workers and helping represent his co-workers to
management. U.S. exports of motorcycles and parts have grown by 15
percent a year from 1987 to 1998, reaching one-third of industry sales.
Harley-Davidson will export 22 percent of the motorcycles produced in
Mr. Ramsey's plant. By 2003, Harley-Davidson expects to double
production from 1996 levels largely because of exports, creating new
jobs for American workers.
"Kodak and its employees have experienced significant gains because of
NAFTA. The NAFTA has enabled Kodak to realize considerable tariff
savings and to make production decisions based on rational economic
grounds rather than on tariff considerations. For example, the
agreement has enabled Kodak to transfer a high-cost sensitizing
operation for color negative film from Mexico to Rochester, New York.
In all, NAFTA has been a win-win-win for Kodak's operations in Canada,
Mexico and the United States."
- Dan Carp, President and CEO of the Eastman Kodak company, credits
NAFTA with Kodak's rapid growth in export sales. Eastman Kodak
manufactures high technology imaging products for sale in 160 countries.
Under NAFTA, Mexican duties on film and photo paper have been reduced
from 15 to 30 percent to 6 to 9 percent, and they will be eliminated by
2004. Kodak's exports to Mexico have more than doubled since 1993,
creating greater stability and more job opportunities for Kodak's 54,000
employees.
Making the Dream of Homeownership a Reality
"I feel true independence in owning my own home. To those who think
it's impossible: It is possible. Don't let anyone talk you out of it."
- Lucy Vocu, a teacher and single mother. Lucy Vocu has lived on the
Pine Ridge reservation all her life. In 1985, Lucy got her GED, and in
1994, she graduated from Oglala Lakota College with a Bachelor of
Science in Elementary Education. She currently works for the Shannon
County school system at Wolf Creek School. Her children, Grace, 15, and
Jacob, 7, spend a lot of time using their computer. Jacob recently
tracked tornadoes on the Internet. Lucy is a first-time homeowner. She
moved from a two-bedroom rental house into this new three-bedroom home,
which offers more privacy. Lucy is excited about being a new homeowner
and, if her budget allows, she hopes to add to her new home a swing set
for Jacob and a basketball net for Grace.
"The social workers at Marion House, which has received funding from
HUD's homeless grants, helped me get back on my feet. They counseled me
on how to find a job and helped me learn the skills I would need to stay
employed. Today I am newly married, and I have been working the last
four years as a secretary for a social service agency. And I am
delighted to say . . . I am a homeowner. Because of your leadership
President Clinton, and because of your commitment to providing funding
for homeless programs across the country, there will be hope and
optimism in place of despair."
- Christa Spangler, of Baltimore, MD, December 23, 1998. Christa
Spangler was a formerly homeless woman who hit rock bottom in 1994 when
she was forced to live in her car. Previously, she had lost custody of
her children, and spent eleven years in and out of halfway houses, rehab
clinics, and hospitals. She found her way to Marion House, a Catholic
transitional housing program for homeless women and children. Christa
is now married, working as a receptionist and living in her own home.
Federal resources pay 25 percent of the Marion House budget.
Empowerment Zones Are a Potent Weapon Against Poverty
"I am living proof that the Empowerment Zone works! If it wasn't for
the Empowerment Zone, I would have never have had the chance to buy this
building or to expand my business. We are fighting the war against
poverty throughout our neighborhoods and cities, but we have a very
potent weapon -- the Empowerment Zones. And we will use that weapon to
win this war because, after all, our future and our children's future
depends on it. We must never give up hope."
- Nancy Santana, 37, is a single mother of three who lives in North
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. She used resources and a loan she obtained
through her local Empowerment Zone to move from welfare to start her own
business, Nancy Santana's Cleaning and Maintenance Services. Four years
later, her business employs over 25 people, many of whom she recruited
off of welfare.
Community Development Financial Institutions Expand Economic Opportunity
"President Clinton's efforts have been very helpful to me. I had
trouble getting funding from other sources. The Enterprise Corporation
of the Delta has worked with me and people in my community, helping us
improve our position in life. Now, I can get into this business, where
otherwise I could not have."
- Ephron Lewis co-founded Lewis & Sons Rice Processing -- the only
African-American-owned rice processing company in the country -- with
his father. The construction of his plant was made possible by a loan
and technical assistance from the Enterprise Corporation of the Delta, a
community development financial institution supported by the Department
of Housing and Urban Development. He now farms roughly 3,000 acres,
producing rice, wheat and soybeans.
Encouraging the Growth of Small Businesses
"I started my small consulting and legal firm with the principle that
everyone should have a shot at the twin American dreams of owning your
own business and owning your own home. I look for the dreamers, the
ones who want to be a part of this country in the best way, but who
don't have the tools and information they need. I hope to be an
instrument of growth and change in Brooklyn's Latino community through
increased business opportunities. This SBA loan will allow me to set up
an office outside my home, close to where I can make the most of the
services I have to offer."
- Enealia Nau, Small Business Owner from Brooklyn, NY. Enealia Nau is
a first-generation American who operates a small business consulting
firm from her home in Brooklyn. After putting herself through college
and law school, Ms. Nau started her consulting firm that focuses on the
legal and financial needs of the minority communities from which she
draws her clients. Ms. Nau helps families from minority communities
realize the American dream through starting their own businesses -- from
beauty shops to corner stores -- and buying their first homes. She has
seen many clients start from nothing and build prosperous lives for
their families through small businesses, including one client who
started with a small "bodega" and now owns one of the largest grocery
stores in Brooklyn.
Expanding Economic Opportunity by Closing the Digital Divide
"Bridging the technology gap in Indian Country is a major challenge, and
I am grateful for the attention that the Clinton Administration has
given to this critical issue. The National Congress of American Indians
is building on the initiatives announced during the President's Digital
Divide tour stop at the Navajo Nation in April 2000 through its Tribal
Leaders Digital Divide Task Force, funded through the AOL Foundation.
Through the Task Force, we are actively working with industry, federal
officials, and others to forge a new tribal-based partnerships and
policy recommendations to close the technology gap."
- Susan Masten, President, National Congress of American Indians, and
Chairwoman, Yurok Tribe. Susan Masten has served as a strong advocate
for the betterment of Native communities on a local, state and national
level for 22 years.
"Community technology centers provide low-income individuals with skills
training and the ability to produce their dreams. They are also an
important entryway to the technology industry. We think of President
Clinton as our first angel investor; his Administration's work has been
fundamental to Plugged In and to the community technology center
movement."
- Magda Escobar, Executive Director, Plugged In, East Palo Alto,
California. East Palo Alto, a low-income community, is located in
Silicon Valley, the epicenter of the technological revolution. Plugged
In trains teenagers and employs them in a web design business; provides
a creative arts and technology studio and after-school program; and
provides community members with access to computers and
telecommunications equipment to increase their employment opportunities.
|